Consignment Stores in Gary, Indiana

Updated August 18, 2025

Find 6 consignment stores in Gary, Indiana. Browse our directory for second-hand treasures, vintage clothing, and pre-loved furniture at great prices.

6 consignment stores found in Gary
Sort by: Popular Rating

6 Consignment Stores in Gary

Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet

4.5
(69 reviews)
Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet

5185 Broadway, Gary, IN 46409

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet stands as a premier resale store strategically located at 5185 Broadway, Gary, IN 46409. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this resale store excels in showcasing high-quality second-hand items. The store maintains an extensive collection of designer clothing, accessories, and luxury goods, providing customers with expertly curated pre-owned collections. Distinguished by its consignment expertise, Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 5185 Broadway, Gary, IN 46409, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. For inquiries and current inventory information, customers can reach the store at +1 219-887-8273. Visitors to Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Thrifty Mac Appliance Bedding & Furniture Outlet continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Miller School Shops & Spaces

4.5
(48 reviews)
Miller School Shops & Spaces

665 S Lake St, Gary, IN 46403

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Miller School Shops & Spaces stands as a premier consignment boutique strategically located at 665 S Lake St, Gary, IN 46403. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this consignment boutique excels in specializing in authenticated pre-owned merchandise. The store maintains an extensive collection of high-end fashion, accessories, and home decor, providing customers with significant savings on premium brands. Distinguished by its quality control processes, Miller School Shops & Spaces has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Miller School Shops & Spaces continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 665 S Lake St, Gary, IN 46403, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at https://millerschoolshops.com/ Visitors to Miller School Shops & Spaces can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Miller School Shops & Spaces continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Goodwill

4.5
(325 reviews)
Goodwill

4830 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Goodwill stands as a premier second-hand retailer strategically located at 4830 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this second-hand retailer excels in delivering exceptional resale shopping experiences. The store maintains an extensive collection of curated fashion pieces, vintage finds, and luxury items, providing customers with sustainable and eco-conscious shopping options. Distinguished by its professional authentication services, Goodwill has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Goodwill continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 4830 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at http://www.goodwill-ni.org/ or contact the store directly at +1 219-595-0652. Visitors to Goodwill can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Goodwill continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore

4.5
(108 reviews)
Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore

6114 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore stands as a premier pre-owned merchandise shop strategically located at 6114 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this pre-owned merchandise shop excels in ensuring authentic pre-owned luxury goods. The store maintains an extensive collection of designer clothing, accessories, and luxury goods, providing customers with unique pieces not found in traditional retail. Distinguished by its expert merchandise selection, Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 6114 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at http://www.nwirestore.org/ or contact the store directly at +1 219-923-7265. Visitors to Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Habitat For Humanity Of Northwest Indiana Restore continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Market City Inc

4.5
(759 reviews)
Market City Inc

4121 Cleveland St, Gary, IN 46408

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Market City Inc stands as a premier second-hand retailer strategically located at 4121 Cleveland St, Gary, IN 46408. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this second-hand retailer excels in showcasing high-quality second-hand items. The store maintains an extensive collection of high-end fashion, accessories, and home decor, providing customers with verified authentic designer items. Distinguished by its authenticated resale services, Market City Inc has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Market City Inc continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 4121 Cleveland St, Gary, IN 46408, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at http://www.marketcityinc.com/ or contact the store directly at +1 219-887-3522. Visitors to Market City Inc can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Market City Inc continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Debbie'S Attic Thrift Shop

4.5
(125 reviews)
Debbie'S Attic Thrift Shop

3535 W Ridge Rd Suite C, Gary, IN 46408

Gary, Indiana

Wide Selection Clean & Organized Friendly Staff
Clothing Antiques Merchandise
Debbie's Attic Thrift Shop stands as a premier curated consignment establishment strategically located at 3535 W Ridge Rd Suite C, Gary, IN 46408. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this curated consignment establishment excels in featuring carefully vetted consignment pieces. The store maintains an extensive collection of premium clothing, shoes, and designer accessories, providing customers with significant savings on premium brands. Distinguished by its detailed item verification, Debbie's Attic Thrift Shop has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Debbie's Attic Thrift Shop continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 3535 W Ridge Rd Suite C, Gary, IN 46408, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. For inquiries and current inventory information, customers can reach the store at +1 219-980-0806. Visitors to Debbie's Attic Thrift Shop can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Debbie's Attic Thrift Shop continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.
View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Consignment Stores Near Gary

Anderson Consignment Stores Angola Consignment Stores Auburn Consignment Stores Aurora Consignment Stores Austin Consignment Stores