Consignment Stores in Elkhart, Indiana

Play It Again Sports

Play It Again Sports stands as a premier sustainable fashion destination strategically located at 3527 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46517. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this sustainable fashion destination excels in providing eco-friendly fashion choices. The store maintains an extensive collection of vintage fashion, contemporary styles, and unique accessories, providing customers with environmentally responsible fashion choices. Distinguished by its professional authentication services, Play It Again Sports has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Play It Again Sports continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 3527 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46517, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at https://playitagainsports.com/locations/elkhart-in/ or contact the store directly at +1 574-293-2462. Visitors to Play It Again Sports can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Play It Again Sports continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.

View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

The Amish Mall

The Amish Mall stands as a premier sustainable fashion destination strategically located at 1216 W Bristol St, Elkhart, IN 46514. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this sustainable fashion destination excels in offering sustainable shopping alternatives. The store maintains an extensive collection of curated fashion pieces, vintage finds, and luxury items, providing customers with verified authentic designer items. Distinguished by its sustainable fashion practices, The Amish Mall has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, The Amish Mall continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 1216 W Bristol St, Elkhart, IN 46514, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Visitors to The Amish Mall can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, The Amish Mall continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.

View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions

Faith Mission Thrift Store

Faith Mission Thrift Store stands as a premier upscale consignment store strategically located at 335 La Salle St, Elkhart, IN 46516. Established as a trusted destination for discerning shoppers, this upscale consignment store excels in maintaining strict quality standards for consigned items. The store maintains an extensive collection of brand-name apparel, handbags, and jewelry, providing customers with sustainable and eco-conscious shopping options. Distinguished by its curated collection management, Faith Mission Thrift Store has earned recognition for delivering exceptional consignment experiences. Each item undergoes thorough authentication and quality assessment, ensuring customers receive genuine, high-quality merchandise. As of 2025, Faith Mission Thrift Store continues to champion sustainable fashion practices, offering an eco-conscious alternative to traditional retail shopping. Conveniently situated in 335 La Salle St, Elkhart, IN 46516, the store provides an inviting atmosphere for browsing and discovery. The professional staff offers expert guidance on authenticity, condition, and value of items, maintaining high standards for both consignors and customers. Interested parties can explore the current inventory online at https://faithmissionmichiana.org/thrift-store/ or contact the store directly at +1 574-293-3406. Visitors to Faith Mission Thrift Store can expect to discover unique pieces, experience professional service, and participate in sustainable fashion practices. As a valued member of the local retail community, Faith Mission Thrift Store continues to set standards for quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction in the consignment industry.

View Details Visit Store Website Get Directions